Skip to Content

The death of Private Stanley Mellish

I always feel a little excluded and cheated when I'm watching a movie scene that involves a foreign language, but no translation subtitles are provided. Case in point, this morning I lay awake watching the second half of Saving Private Ryan. I'm not a big fan of war stories, but the "Knife Fight" scene stuck with me for a while.

I figured I would have to dig around for the translation of the script that I was curious about, but suprisingly the third result of my Google search for "saving private ryan knife stab german" provided the answer.

The scene is The death of Private Stanley Mellish (Adam Goldberg) - watch it on YouTube. It's much better in context (with Upham just metres away on the staircase), which I've removed from the below commentary:

As the final battle wages on, Mellish is fighting one-on-one against a German soldier. The German slowly gains the upper hand. Mellish pulls out a knife, but the German is too strong, and pushes Mellish's hand backwards, pointing the blade towards the American's chest. Mellish starts to beg. "Wait a minute. Wait a minute".

The German slowly pushes the knife into Mellish's chest, quietly whispering something in German, which translates as "Give up, you don't stand a chance! Let's end this here; it will be easier for you like this!".

Mellish shakes as his life leaves him and the German leaves the room.

Mellish also screams "Wait what's that mean? What's that mean?! STOP!!" which left me wondering myself.

If you have time to waste check out Saving Private Ryan vs Finding Nemo. It's funny and a lot less serious. Buuubbbllessss! Bubbbllless!!

 

One Comment

31 January 2008
09:23 am

craig parker

I know exactly what you mean by how this scene stuck with you. I walked out the cinema with some friends and one of them, who’s German, kindly translated for us. As translations go, we seldom even get the full effect of it even in written form or as subtitles. But apparently what’s also mentioned to Mellish was something like: ‘Sshhhhhh….it’ll be over soon.’

Haunting.

Leave a Comment

Your e-mail address is required, but will not be published.

 
 
 

Tags allowed:  <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>