Skip to Content

Public voting for 2010 poster opens

Public voting for 2010 poster opens, via BizCommunity:

South African residents are being invited to make their voices heard from today by voting for one of three designs to become the official poster of the 2010 FIFA World Cup. It is the second time since the 2006 FIFA World Cup in Germany (see those poster designs) that the residents of the host country are actively involved in the selection of the official event poster.

From a total of 16 creative entries, all submitted solely by South-African [sic] based agencies, three proposals have been pre-selected by a jury.

Go choose your favourite, and stand the chance to win two FIFA World Cup tickets provided by MTN! The deadline for voting is midnight on 30 September 2007. You can also vote via SMS or phone.

Poster 1Poster 2Poster 3

Unfortunately it seems as though FIFA need to work on their geolocation sniffing because on attempting to vote, I was presented with the following error message:

We are sorry to inform you that you cannot take part in the voting because either your point of access does not appear to be in South Africa or you do not reside in the country.

They'd better correct this ASAP otherwise the exercise will be a huge failure.

Also it's a pity the posters can't be viewed at a larger resolution, and why only 3 final designs? And why only 16 entries? Was this an invitation-only competition? I suspect details of the process will be revealed later and I'll be interested to hear how this was handled, because I can imagine a number of designers and agencies calling "foul" again.

I like them all for different reasons, but prefer the middle one, because it has more impact and I love the face/continent combination - although the plain yellow background is a little boring and feels incomplete. The first one doesn't say much to me and doesn't have much of an African feel (it might be losing detail at that resolution?), while the last one is well executed and clever, but perhaps overly so. There's something about it that makes me feel uncomfortable.

Judging by the similarity in colour, I suspect they were all subject to strict FIFA guidelines, as with the official logo.

Which is your favourite?

UPDATE [12/09]: The voting page has been updated with the following:

Please be aware that you have to perform the following steps to submit your vote on FIFA.com:

  1. You need to access FIFA.com from South Africa (reflected by your IP Address).
  2. You need to create a FIFA.com Club Member Account (registration is quick, easy and free).
  3. You have to be a resident of South Africa (reflected by the choice of country in your FIFA.com Club profile).

I doubt this will encourage many to vote... how disappointing!

 

5 Comments

11 September 2007
09:43 pm

lebogang nkoane

I’d go with the first one, but then gain, you are right, nothing African about it. The second one, I don’t quit like the copy right on the edge of the west-coast of Africa, the third one should not have made it onto the list, ‘mama Africa’?

Any who, i got the same problem, with geo-location, i think they want us to use the ‘cellphone’ voting, so MTN can make it’s money back from the free tickets, :-)

12 September 2007
01:53 am

Shaal

South African’s are lucky to get so much exposure worldwide, in the form of sports events, The football worldcup, the today started Twenty20 Cricket worldup, the under-19 cricket series,i am forgetting a couple more events that are happening this year… but Football worldcup is my most awaited event~ Lets see how things go for the Southern Africa~

12 September 2007
08:42 am

Richard

I had the same problem with geo-location so I just sms’ed it in. Personally, I like B.

13 September 2007
03:27 pm

Z

Forced registration?
Nooit bru.

None of them look captivate me, but out of these 3 i’d go with B. ugh

14 September 2007
12:35 am

Rex

I would vote for the 2nd one specially the way guy is looking at Football……..Like he wana win

Leave a Comment

Your e-mail address is required, but will not be published.

 
 
 

Tags allowed:  <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>