Skip to Content

Were they even thinking?

There's good design. There's bad design. Then there's the "holy crap! what the hell were they thinking?" kind.

Listed on netdiver's Best of the Year 2004 page, AmoebaCorp: Graphic Design and Visual Communications Company in Toronto. I only clicked on their listing because I've always liked the name. Say it with me, "amoeba"..."amoeba"..."a-m-o-e-b-a-a-a-a"... ok! Moving on...

Unique, innovative, stellar concept and craftmanship - is not how I would categorize them. I've never encountered a website with such a frustrating and pointless site-wide navigation system. You'll probably check it out now. It will resize and reposition your web browser window. That might annoy you. After making a silly decision on their splash screen - you choose the Flash option (yes, Flash 7) because it's more prominent and "rock and roll" - it will launch in a popup window. That might annoy you. The popup window might be blocked by your browser. That will annoy you.

So you're finally in the site? Great - let's play a game!
Before we start, I suggest you disable the sound in the top right corner by clicking on the N. It doesn't really disable the sound, it just gets rid of the music. I guarantee, after the novelty of those bleeps and distorted frog croaks wears off, it will drive you insane.

+10 points if you can figure out how the navigation works; -10 points if you develop a headache trying. +10 points if you can navigate to the "contact" page on first attempt; -10 points if you land up somewhere else or get stuck in some other section for over a minute.

In retrospect, this example is probably better classified as a "were they even thinking?" kind of design.

 

4 Comments

10 January 2005
07:05 am

Jacques

I’d recommend that they visit a company like 37Signals or Adaptive Path to get their Usability sorted out. Even their HTML version of the site is annoying.

10 January 2005
11:44 am

Rogier

LOL, I immediately clicked on the link to their site, and after I relaunched the site, (because Firefox blocked it ;) ), I disabled the sound, but the bleeps were still there. I figured it didn’t work correctly. Than I started clicking on the links in the bottom area of the screen, but alas, nothing worked. Hmmmz….

Later, I found out I could drag that line-thingie around. Phew.

10 January 2005
01:14 pm

David

Better should have been “Best of the Year 2000″!

11 January 2005
11:50 pm

Edgard

I checked out a few more netdiver entries. A lot of them (if not all) are bad examples regarding accessibility and standards.

Leave a Comment

Your e-mail address is required, but will not be published.

 
 
 

Tags allowed:  <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>